Murder, hip-hop and hypocrisy.
The death of Denver Broncos cornerback Darrent Williams has brought out the moralizers, and partly for good reason. But Mike Celizic goes a little far in his MSNBC article.
If Williams was going to die, the cold statistics of death in these United States say that this was the most likely way for it to happen. Young males are a high-risk group of which to be a part to begin with, but that’s especially so if your skin is dark. Young white males die most often of accidents or suicide; young black males die most often of gunshot wounds. ...
If Williams had been shot by police, there would be rallies with thousands of persons demanding justice. If one or more of the cops were white, Al Sharpton would be front and center, demanding an end to the victimization of young blacks by law enforcement officials.
But it is likely that this will turn out to be another black-on-black shooting. And that’s a lot harder to get a soundbite out of. Besides, to condemn it would require condemning a culture that too often celebrates in music and lifestyle guns and retribution and a twisted idea of honor. ... The common thread is people who feel powerless and disenfranchised by society. For most of us, the American Dream is a good job, 1.6 perfect children and a home in the suburbs. For too many, the dream is a Glock and somebody to use it on.
Al Sharpton, who Celizic calls out in his article, would likely be on his side in this situation. When a disagreement between rappers 50 Cent and The Game ended in a shooting, Sharpton laughably called for a government ban on violent rap music -- making the same mistake many do that rap music is a direct cause of violence.
Condemning murder would mean condemning hip-hop culture? Being powerless and disenfranchised leads to wanting to kill someone? This, from a generally rational sportswriter? What does Mike Celizic know about being poor? What does Mike Celizic know about 'the ghetto'? He comes up with these conclusions based on stereotypes and perception and ends up sounding like a fool. This whole idea of "inner city" being synonymous with guns, violence and death is wrong. There is no question that too many young people, black or white, are dying because of guns. There is no question that there is too much violence, that there are too many gangs. But to assign to a culture, a music and a race the characteristics of getting shot or shooting someone is wrong and ignorant -- whether Al Sharpton is doing it by calling for a ban on rap or Mike Celizic is doing it in an effort to vent his moral outrage at America.
Darrent Williams got shot by a fool with a gun. That fool happened to be black. And right away, people come to the conclusion that this fool was a gangster from the inner city who listens to rap music. That may be true. But those aren't requirements to being an irresponsible, violent criminal.
Celizic is like so many people, white and black, who blames violence on music and clothes, as if someone who wears a suit and tie and listens to Frank Sinatra isn't capable of murder. The vast majority of serial killers and rapists in this country are white males. In fact, "Every single sexual deviation is overwhelmingly dominated by white males. And most sexually related ritualistic crimes are committed by white males." Does anyone assign to white men and their associated culture the characteristics of rapist or murderer? Does anyone write articles decrying the music they listen to or the clothes they wear?
Of course not. The actions of some are not the actions of all, and the murderers, rapists and general deviants are not the majority. Bill Cosby would have people believe that all young black men are listening to rap music, becoming corrupted and becoming thugs. And people like Mike Celizic listen to those statements and believe it is their place to make judgments based on them. But if rap music and hip hop culture were so dangerous and convincing, then why aren't murders occurring constantly, in every single city and neighborhood in America? Hip hop isn't limited to poor inner city black America. Millions of white teenagers blast rap and hip hop into their ears on a daily basis. How come we don't hear Sharpton and Celizic worrying that hip hop will turn these white children into criminals?
The death of Williams is a tragedy, and people always look for someone or something to blame in a situation like this. But Celizic was wrong in looking to and making generalizations about hip hop culture. Hip hop is not responsible for everything wrong in the world.

3 comments:
"Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but not their own facts." - Daniel Patrick Moynihan
The vast majority of serial killers and rapists in this country are white males.
According to the United States Dept. of Justice, 48.5 percent of rape offenders are black (compared with 32.8 white, 15.4 percent "other" and 3.2 percent not known). Meanwhile, black males make up approximately 6.5 percent of the country. Furthermore, serial killers are so rare that to break them down by race is pure silliness. Violent crime rates, however, are seven times higher for blacks compared to whites. (http://tinyurl.com/6msws)
Your overall point about not generalizing based on the actions of a few are worth noting. But your usage of incorrect or misleading "facts" equating only hurts your case. Rap music may not be the cause of the violent crime problem for blacks in America, but that doesn't mean there isn't a problem -- and, yes, a problem within the black community far more so than the white one. (Of course, there are many, many reasons for this, not least of which is racism towards blacks, but that's a topic for another day...)
Celizic may not be qualified to tackle the violence problem in the US, but he should be applauded for having the courage to address it.
This whole idea of "inner city" being synonymous with guns, violence and death is wrong.
Bwahahaha!!!!
But if rap music and hip hop culture were so dangerous and convincing, then why aren't murders occurring constantly, in every single city and neighborhood in America?
Umm ... murders are happening every day - in the ghetto. Hello?
Millions of white teenagers blast rap and hip hop into their ears on a daily basis. How come we don't hear Sharpton and Celizic worrying that hip hop will turn these white children into criminals?
Maybe because these millions of white teenagers aren't killing each other? You think that might be one reason? Put away the guns, young black people. For the sake of everyone.
From the Denver Post:
Rev. Leon Kelly, who helps Denver teens avoid or escape gangs, said he heard that on Monday morning at the club that Williams was with members of one street gang and that they had a conflict with members of a rival gang, to which Hicks belongs.
In the gang world, respect is a major issue, Kelly said. Someone may have felt disrespected.
Williams didn't need to have gang ties to be in danger, Kelly said. People die over being around someone who does.
The moral of the story? Don't hang around gang members.
http://www.denverpost.com/ci_4942657
Post a Comment